Should Marijuana be Legalized?

comments 4
Political Philosophy / Society & Culture

I’m asking this question in hopes that we can generate an interesting discussion, and because I really don’t have a solid position on this controversial issue. Traditionally, I have leaned toward “No” – after all, marijuana is seen as a “gateway drug” that leads people into playing with much greater fires. Also, there’s the question of whether we want to make such a vice more prevalent in society.


The prohibition of Marijuana, which is arguably less destructive than alcohol, has created a huge black-market economy with all of the shady characters that go with it, and it is rampant in our schools and on our streets. If and when a teen decides to try it out, there is no telling what is in it or where it came from. On the positive side I can think of several things that legalization – which does not necessarily mean an endorsement – would immediately do:

1. It would allow for the regulation of the production and sale of marijuana, making it safer and cleaner.

2. It would reduce the load (and cost) on our law enforcement, court system and detention facilities.

3. It would make the $11 billion per year marijuana industry (by most estimates) a taxable commodity

4. It would take profits out of the hands of criminals, and allow law-abiding entrepreneurs to start businesses, create jobs, etc.

If regulated, the most dangerous aspect of marijuana use that I can foresee is that the drug’s effects are much more immediate than that of alcohol, and more debilitating than tobacco. Whereas most people need several drinks to induce intoxication, marijuana can do the trick in minutes. This could lead to a dramatic increase in fatal accidents and sexual misconduct, among other things. On the other hand, the effects of marijuana are very different from alcohol. How often do you hear of some guy beating up his wife because he smoked a joint? Perhaps making marijuana a legal option would curb alcohol use. Then, maybe not.

One of the benefits of a federal system in the U.S. is what political scientists call the “laboratory of democracy,” which means that states can try things out and see how they work before trying them on a national scale. While I could see this argument being made for experimenting with legalization I think that doing so in only a few states would drive crime into those areas and add another dimension to the black market. I think in order for legalization to have any positive outcome it would have to be nationwide.

Please contribute.


Disclaimer: This post should not be taken as an endorsement of marijuana use, nor does it address moral values. I am simply raising questions for the sake of discussion.

The Author

read the "about me" section


  1. Susan Osteen Gant says

    Your 4 points are fantastic! Maybe it should be legalized.

    If legalized:
    1) The “penalties” for “Driving Under the Influence of Marijuana” should have severely stiff, in order to keep people from using & driving. (of course, only lately has the “DWI” become so important, with urging from the Mothers Against Drunk Driving)

    2) The “laboratory of democracy” may not make crime rise in those places, because it would only be “legal” to purchase from a “licensed” dealer. Anyone caught, just as now, would definitely be in major trouble!!

    3) It may lessen the stigma that it is a ‘gateway drug’ because the people selling it would not also be supplying heroin, pcp, meth and other hard drugs which are so readily available. (With strict regulation from the ATF, it would make the ‘premises’ easily accessible–not hidden, like in the dark alleyways now.)

    PRO: The money funded to the state and county systems could be redirected to improve communities.

    In general:
    1) I’ve come to see alcohol as equally unforgiving therefore, people who smoke pot would probably be making a “better” bad choice.

    2)Never having smoked marijuana, I cannot totally condemn or approve of it from a personal standpoint.

    Main causes for opposition:
    1) secondhand smoke (especially to children)
    2) Christian beliefs

  2. wesley says

    I agree – if it is legalized there should be very strict rules and heavy punishments.

    The reason I say crime would increase in states if only a few of them legalize it is because there would be a massive smuggling operation by criminals who go into those states to buy it legally and come back home to sell it on the local black market.

    You mention that one of your reasons for opposing is your Christian beliefs. I think it’s fair to say “hey, I don’t want people to do this, so I will do everything I can to reduce it.” However, I think we also have to consider whether the law is the appropriate mechanism for stopping “bad” behavior. There are lots of things in our society that we would prefer to see go away, but do you make it illegal? Should we make criminals out of people who eat junk food because it is bad for them? Should we put people behind bars for watching an X-Rated film in the privacy of their home?

    Of course we don’t want to encourage these behaviors, but you can see how using the law to prevent people from it leads us down a slippery slope.

  3. Today Nike footwear are renwoned for their versatile styles all through the world. They are incredibly warm and sizzling sorts of footwear certainly. They comprise worthwhile colors, shapes, and sizes which would absolutely fascinate for your hearts all of the time. Nike footwear maintain incredibly imaginative models which would catch your vision about the dot. For example, when it arrives for the operating shoe, it may be the most stylish Nike shoe inside globe nowadays which seems in 3 matchless models along the lines of neutral, cushioned, movement controlled. Bear in thoughts that Nike operating footwear are one of the best footwear for your sportsmen inside globe today. Similarly when we speak concerning the Nike basketball footwear they are one of the most great footwear for your sports activities people inside world. Thirdly we cannot deny the versatility of Nike football and soccer footwear by any indicates simply because they have captivated large attentions in the sportsmen these days. Fourthly Nike the game of golf footwear are preferred footwear for your globe broad golfers. Besides, there are several other exclusive fashions of Nike footwear that are indescribable at all.Nike footwear are incredibly lovely, enchanting and fascinating footwear for all of the globe broad sportsmen. They not merely provide you with a sheer item of handle within your lifestyle but additionally supply you a large psychological relaxation. For example, for individuals who undoubtedly are a football and searching for any sort of shoe to obtain back again your true speed, then absolutely nothing shall be a higher alternative in your case than making use of Nike football shoe whatsoever simply because this can not merely provide you with a sort of spark into your rate but additionally lift up your sportsman spirit stunningly. on the existing time, Nike footwear are becoming extensively produced by many sorts of footwear establishments all through the world. Heavy components could be applied for bringing forth exclusive Nike footwear for your sportsmen. They are incredibly versatile shoes. They are incredibly resilient along with lengthy lasting shoes. They possess a definite spark. When it arrives for the colour impressions, Nike footwear do have several worthwhile colours past your imagination.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s